Home Page Overview Site Map Index Appendix Illustration About Contact Update FAQ


Origin of the Universe


Contents

Quantization of the Friedmann Equation (Matter-only)
Quantization of the Empty Universe (-only)
Theory of Cosmic Inflation
Quantum Fluctuations and Cosmic Structures


Quantization of the Friedmann Equation (Matter-only)

There are many theories for the origin of the universe. Some of them are classical, while others take the quantum effect into account. The path to quantum gravity is usually via quantization of the gravitational field which endows the field with particle identity. Such treatment is not very
Energy Level and Cosmic Expansion successful as infinities keep coming up in the formulation. A less ambitious way is to quantize the Friedmann equation for a homogeneous and isotropic universe when the size of the universe was at the Planck scale of 1.6x10-33cm; then the whole universe can be considered as a small particle (with certain mass and size). By quantizing the dimensionless scale factor R and its time derivative dR/dt, this particle is endowed with a wave property; the corresponding wave function can be interpreted as the probability amplitude at certain value of the scale factor R. It turns out that the resulting wave equation is similar to that for the electron in the hydrogen atom (with different interpretations of the parameters). In particular, the energy in the case of hydrogen atom is now replaced by the spatial curvature k. The transition from its extremely large value to small number corresponding to a nearly flat space can be interpreted as quantum jump to near continuum during the period of inflation. Figure 01a compares the energy levels of the hydrogen atom and the inverse of the spatial curvature (~ radius of curvature) in cosmic expansion. The appearance seems to be in reverse since the correspondence is between E (energy level) and k (spatial curvature), and the plot is for 1/k to make it looking like the expansion of the universe.

Figure 01a Energy Level and Cosmic Expansion

This formulation is similar to the Wheeler-DeWitt equation, which is also derived from the Friedmann equation with an un-specified potential. This treatment adopts a potential corresponding to a matter-only universe. The other
alternative with "cosmological constant -only" is explored in the section on "Quantization of the Empty Universe".

See also the conclusion in "Realm of Planck Scale" about not to generalize too much of the Friedmann equation beyond the period of inflation.

Following is the mathematical derivation (for the matter only "Quantization of the Friedmann Equation") :

The classical Friedmann equation for a matter-only homogeneous and isotropic universe is in the form :

(dR/dt)2 - 2GM / Rr3 = -kc2 ----- (1)

where the various mathematical symbols are now re-interpreted such that M is the mass of a particle at the moment of the Big Bang, r is its radius, k is the spatial curvature of this entity, t the comoving time, and R the dimension-less scale factor replacing the role of spatial coordinates.

Quantization of a particle is prescribed by the commutative relation : [px, x] = pxx - xpx = -i, where px = m dx/dt is the momentum along the x axis. This equation is satisfied if px = -i d/dx and operates on a (wave) function . In order to follow this quantization rule for the case of cosmic expansion, we can assign R to take the place of x and construct an entity having the dimension of ergs-sec = gm-cm2/sec (the dimension of ) such as Mr2dR/dt. Thus the commutative rule becomes:

[Mr2dR/dt, R] = -i, which can be satisfied for Mr2dR/dt = -i d/dR    or    dR/dt = (-i/Mr2) d/dR.

Then the quantized Friedmann equation can be written as :

d2/dR2 + (M2r4c2/2)[(2GM/c2r3R) - k] = 0 ----- (2)

By substituting = R , this equation can be re-cast to :

d2/dR2 + (2/R)d/dR + (M2r4c2/2)[(2GM/c2r3R) - k] = 0 ----- (3)

which is in a form similar to the Schrodinger Equation for hydrogen atom :

d2/dr2 + (2/r)d/dr + (2m/2)[(e2/r) + E] = 0 ----- (4)

the solution of which yields the energy :

E = - (me4/22)(1/n2) ----- (5)

and the normalized wave function = [2/(nr0)½] (1/n2r0) e-r/nr0 Ln-1(1)(2r/nr0)  ----- (6),

where the generalized Laguerre polynomial (of differentiating once) Ln-1(1)(x) = (-1)j[n!/(n-j-1)!(j+1)!j!]xj
and the innermost Bohr orbit r0 = 2/me2 .

Wave Function By substituting k to -E, R to r, M2r4c2/2 to 2m/2, and 2GM/c2r3 to e2, the quantized Friedmann equation yields :

k = (2GM/c2r3)2 (M2r4c2/42)(1/n2) = G2M4/r2c22n2  ----- (7),

= 2[(R/nR0)/(nR0)½](1/n) e-R/nR0 Ln-1(1)(2R/nR0)  ----- (8),

where R0 = (c2r3/2GM) (22/M2r4c2) = 2/GM3r . The Laguerre polynomial and wave function for a few low laying states are listed in Table 01 below (also see Figure 01b).

Figure 01b Wave Function


n Ln-1(1)(x) n(R)
1 1 [2(R/R0)/(R0)½] e-R/R0
2 2(1 - x/2) [2(R/2R0)/(2R0)½] (1 - R/2R0) e-R/2R0
3 3(1 - x + x2/6) [2(R/3R0)/(3R0)½] [(1 - 2(R/3R0) + (2/3)(R/3R0)2] e-R/3R0
n-1 n[1 - (n-1)(x/2) + ...
(-1)n-1(xn-1/n!)]
[2(R/nR0)/(nR0)½][(1 - 2(R/nR0) + ... (-1)n-1 (2n-1/n!)(R/nR0)n-1] e-R/nR0

Table 01 Laguerre polynomial and Wave Function

The view of Loop Quantum Gravity is adopted by assuming the universe to begin with minimum length r = the Planck length Lp = (G/c3)½ = 1.6x10-33cm. However for the Planck mass Mp = (c/G)½ = 2.17x10-5gm, its corresponding Schwarzschild Radius rs is equal to twice the Planck length, i.e., rs = 2GMp/c2 = 2Lp implying the initial radius r is inside the event horizon, i.e., the particle is a black hole. It has been shown that such black hole would evaporate rapidly in 10-40 sec (see Black Hole Evaporation) about the scale of the Planck time (see "World of Planck Scale").

3-D White Hole An article in "New Scientist, January 2-8 2016" with the title "Quantum Bounce" postulates that the collapse to black hole can be reversed to ejection from white hole by the space-time loop in the "Theory of Loop Quantum Gravity" (Figure 01c). Calculations show that bigger black hole would take longer to bounce. Thus, the authors are looking for evidences from small black holes more common in earlier history of universe; and that's why we don't see such event nearby. However, nobody would perceive the very slow process that turns the whole universe from its previous collapsing cycle back to the expansion phase today. This idea is similar to the black hole evaporation. Therefore from such perspectives, the event horizon is not a barrier for expansion.

Figure 01c 3-D White Hole

See earlier work on "LQG Cosmology".
BTW, the collapse of astronomical objects is not the only way to create black holes. Simulation in 2018 reveals that collision of energetic gravitational waves can also make black hole (see "Freak Gravitational Waves Could Rorm Black Holes and Destroy Earth").

Probability Spreading Anyway, expressing in term of the Planck length, k and R0 can be written in a very simple form :

k = 1/(n2Lp2) = 40x1064/n2 cm-2, and R0 = 1 ----- (9).

In analogy to the Bohr radius for hydrogen atom, R0r = Lp for n = 1 can be identified as the classical radius of the particle at ground state (Figure 01d), and R0/ = nLp would be the radius of curvature as depicted in Figure 01a.

The commutative rule becomes : [t0(dR/dt), R] = -i,
where t0 = tPl = (G/c5)½ = 5.4x10-44 sec and dR/dt = (-i/t0)d/dR so that
[-i(d/dR), R] = -i.

Figure 01d Probability Distribution


The "Theory of Inflation" was introduced to address the astronomical puzzle of a flat and homogeneous (and isotropic) universe. Although homogeneous and isotropic conditions have been built into the Friddmann equation explicitly, it is the small size which ensures whatever inside had enough time to mix. The quantization is able to replicate the expansion without additional assumption by considering excitation to nearly continuum of the principle quantum n. Thus, for the transition from n = 1 to n 2x1034, the spatial curvature would lower drastically to k 10-3 cm-2. Thus, the problem with the flatness of the universe can be explained as quantum jump to highly excited state. The transition to classic theory occurred naturally since such highly excited levels are crowded together like a continuum, where the discreteness characterized by quantum theory is lost. This theory has another virtue, e.g., the explosive expansion automatically stops with the end of the transition - unlike the original inflation theory, which requires a specific mechanism to have it terminated or it inflates forever creating endless universes.

[Top]


Quantization of the Empty Universe (-only)

Quantitization of the classical Friedmann equation for the -only homogeneous and isotropic universe is rather problematic as shown below. Anyway, for those who don't mind the mathematical detail, it starts from the classical form :

(dR/dt)2 + (k - R2/3)c2 = 0 --------- (10)

where is the cosmological constant, k is the curvature of space, t the comoving time, and R the dimension-less scale factor.

In order to follow the conventional quantization rule with the commutative relation : [px, x] = pxx - xpx = -i, we can assign R to take the place of x and construct an entity having the dimension of ergs-sec = gm-cm2/sec (the dimension of ) such as (c2L3/G)dR/dt, where L is the linear size of the early universe. Thus the commutative rule becomes:

[(c2L3/G)dR/dt, R] = -i, which can be satisfied with (c2L3/G)dR/dt = -i d/dR,     or     dR/dt = -i(G/c2L3)d/dR ---------- (11).

Then the quantized Friedmann equation can be written as :

Quantum Harmonic Oscillator Hermite Polynomials

Figure 01h Quantum Harmonic Oscillator [view large image]

Figure 01i Hermite Polynomials
[view large image]

Pseudo-sphere The eigenvalue and eigenfunction for the quantum harmonic oscillator is respectively :
En = (n + 1/2) ---------- (13a),
n = (m/)1/4(2nn!)-1/2Hn(y)e-y2 ---------- (13b),
where y = (m/)1/2, 2 = /m, and Hn(y) is the Hermit Polynomials (see Figures 01h, 01i).
The corresponding solutions to the quantum empty universe's are :
kn = k = -|k| = -(n + 1/2)(2/a0r0) ---------- (14a),
n = (1/a0r0)1/4(2nn!)-1/2Hn[(r0/a0)1/2 R]e-(r0/a0)R2 ---------- (14b)

Figure 01j Pseudo-sphere
[view large image]

If the initial size of the universe L and (3/||)1/2 are taken to be the Planck length LP = (G/c3)1/2 = 1.62x10-33 cm, then r0 ~ a0 ~ LP, the expressions assume the simple forms :
kn = -(n + 1/2)[2/(LP)2] with the ground state curvature k0 = -1/(LP)2 ---------- (15a),
n = (1/LP2)1/4(2nn!)-1/2Hn(R)e-R2 ---------- (15b),
and the corresponding energy density = ||c4/(8G) = 5.4x10113 erg/cm3, which is very close to the controversial vacuum energy density calculated for the purported dark energy.
Another model of empty quantum universe under the title "Wave function of the Universe" had been developed in 1983 by Hartle and Hawking. It specifies a positive curvature k = +1 cm-2 and positive cosmological constant . Other than that, the quantized Friedmann Equation is essentially in the same form as Eq.(12a) differing by a factor of R2 in the 2nd term, that is :

d2/dR2 - V(R) = 0 ---------- (16a),
where V(R) = k(r0)2R2[1 - R2/(a0k1/2)2] ---------- (16b),
and shown graphically in Figure 01k, where k = +1 cm-2 is from the assumption.
It is in the form of a potential barrier for R/(a0k1/2) < 1, then becomes a potential well after R/(a0k1/2) = 1.

Solution of Eq.(16a) is published in "Quantum Cosmology for Pedestrians" and shown below in a slightly different format :

 Potential  Wavefunction

Figure 01k -only Potential [view large image]

Figure 01l -only Wavefunction [view large image]

Actaully, the formulation has a serious conceptual problem, here's the comments :
See a more sensible model in "Quantization of the Friedmann Equation (Matter-only)". Simply put, such model requires a factor 1/R (via the volume of whatever entity) in the "potential" term of Eq.(1).

[Top]


Theory of Cosmic Inflation

The theory of cosmic inflation has been introduced to resolve some observational astronomical features in 1980. Since then it has received ample supports from both WMAP and Planck. However, in the absence of a quantum-gravity theory its foundation is not solid, it often resorts to ad hac assumption which relies on special form of potential and is not quantum mechanical and/or relativistic. Anyway, a brief re-visit of the "forced and damped oscillations" would clarify somewhat the mystery shrouded behind the subject.

Damped Oscillation Damped and Force Wave

Figure 02a Different Types of Solution [view large image]

Figure 02b Damped and Forced Oscillation [view large image]


Suppose at one spatial point in the dawn of the universe, it contained a homogeneous scalar field (t). As it will be shown in the followings, this is the inflaton that drives the inflation and later on becomes the Higgs field endowing mass to all particles (see "Could the Higgs Boson be the Inflaton?"). It can be shown (see for example "Early Universe") that the energy density and the pressure p associated with the scalar field can be expressed in the form (in natural units):
Inflaton Potential Inflaton Continuity Eq. N-S Eqs.

Figure 03a Inflaton Potential

Figure 03b Inflaton Field

Initially, the force drives the inflaton field toward the true vacuum, then it blocks further change and the field oscillates to complete stop (Figures 3a,b). In particular, V can take the form V() = (1/2)m22 + (/4!)4, in which m2 is negative for endowing mass to particles (see "Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking").

Figure 03a depicts this form of V graphically showing the false and true vacuum at dV/d = 0. The scalar field has been solved numerically using this form of potential with a little push (small d/dt) in the beginning to start the process. The result shown in Figure 03b is not quite satisfactory as it reaches the steady state too soon. A more realistic scenario is shown in the inserts (Figure 03a), in which the potential falls off much more gently allowing a slow-roll to the true vacuum. Note that the general form of is similar to the damped oscillation with a constant force in Figure 02b.

Figure 03b also plots the inflaton energy density (blue), and pressure p (black) as functions of the time t. It shows that the inflaton energy density and pressure vanish as it settles down to the true vacuum. The inflaton field at true vacuum can be identified as the Higgs field discovered on July, 2012. While the inflaton energy is converted to mass/energy of particles in this world, the negative pressure is responsible for driving the exponential expansion in this phase.

Now a word about the Hubble parameter H, which is derived from standard cosmology and can be written as (for k = 0) :

where Mp = 1/(8G)1/2 is the reduced Planck mass, and o is the total mass density of the system in Planck scale (= 5x1093 gm/cm3), which is related to Vo = oc2 = 10114 erg/cm3. It remains to be a constant during the exchange of energy between the inflaton's and particles' until the end of the inflation (see Figure 01f). Thus according to this scenario the early exponential expansion depends on the value of H = c(/3)1/2 = (o/3Mp2)1/2 = constant 2.6x1043 sec-1. Ultimately, the inflation is caused by the constant energy density Vo during that period. (see the simple mathematics to demonstrate the effect of constant energy density on gravitational force). During this period, the cosmological constant =2.3 1066 cm-2, i.e., a 10123 folds difference from the value in the current epoch. See a 2015 update on "Vacuum Energy Density".

Eternal Inflation Eternal inflation is a peculiar property arising from the concept of inflation. The above-mentioned scenario is for just one point in space. It has been suggested that every point in the space can be initially in a false vacuum state. The decay to true vacuum happens randomly similar to the decay of radioactive substance. The difference is the continuously growing of the false vacuum (FV). As depicted in Figure 04b, the FV itself inflates continuously getting bigger and bigger (cannot be shown in the drawing). Those decayed regions are the "pocket universe" like ours, which keeps on expanding but not in exponential rate.

Figure 04b Eternal Inflation [view large image]


The chaotic inflation proposes that false vacuum with sufficient high energy density can pop up randomly within the the normally expanding universe. Exploration of variations on the inflationary theme has produced many speculative "theories" such as extra-dimension, multiverse, many worlds, pre-BigBang, ...

See "problems with the theory of inflation".

[Top]


Quantum Fluctuations and Cosmic Structures

Exponential Expansion About a year after the introduction of the theory of inflation without considering any quantum effect, it was realized that quantum fluctuations in the initial region could have a profound consequence as tiny imperfection would become huge defect with the cosmic expansion (Figure 05a). Since then theoretical calculations yield close agreements with observations in the forms of CMBR power spectrum and super-clusters structures. The basic assumptions, the different kinds of spectrum, the link of gravitational potential fluctuations to the other types, and the evolution of the fluctuations to astronomical objects will be explored in the followings. In order to understand what it is all about, it is crucial to define the relationship between the fluctuation and power spectrum.

Figure 05a Exponential Expansion

Fourier Transform Gaussian Distribution

Figure 05b Fourier Transform

Figure 05c Gaussian Distribution

The power spectrum has the general form with index n : P(k) = Akn, where A is a constant. For n = 1, P(k)/k = d(2)/dk = A = constant, the variance receives equal contributions from a given range of k. The gravitational potential fluctuation is said to be scale invariance as shown in Figure 05d. It is estimated that (x) is of the order 10-4 at kc = H ot t = 1/H. BTW, the power index n is also referred to as scalar spectral index ns in CMB jargon.
Power Spectrum Inflaton Field Fluctuation

Figure 05d Power Spectrum and Cosmic Fluctuations

Figure 05e Quantum Fluctuation

This is the original fluctuation emerged soon after the inflation. Since then its shape has been modified beyond recognition by interaction with various kinds of substance. The square of the gravitational potential fluctuation in k-space is plotted in Figure 05e for t = H-1.

Ultimately, the quantum fluctuation during the inflation period is created out of the virtual particle pair. Similar to the Hawking radiation generated at the event horizon of the black hole, the pair can be separated by the Hubble horizon preventing them from recombination back to the vacuum and thus become frozen (real wave, not virtual anymore) as shown in Figure 05f. This condition is applicable for those long wavelength (small k) fluctuations outside the Hubble horizon (sphere) dH = c/H since the fluctuating duration according to the uncertainty principle is t ~ /c, i.e.,
Quantum Fluctuation Cosmic Horizon more free time for longer wavelength. In Figure 05g the frozen waves are shown as if they are trapped under the "mountain" (it may take a moment to appreciate the contents as it plots everything inverse to length, i.e., inside out; contrary to the normal perception in the insert). As expansion of the universe continues, new particle waves are frozen on top of the previously ones. The process goes on until the end of the inflation when the universe already becomes populated by inhomogeneous fluctuations (see insert in Diagram a, Figure 05d). They become the source of mass-energy density fluctuations (Diagram e) leading to gravitational fluctuations

Figure 05f Quantum Fluctuation

Figure 05g Cosmic Horizon
[view large image]

(Diagram d) and eventually the wall/void in super-galactic cluster and the temperature variations in the CMBR.

Followings is a short recap to trace the fluctuations from the invisible inflaton to something that is tangible (Figure 05h).
Acoustic Materials

Figure 05h Formation of CMBR Spectrum and Cosmic Large Structures [view large image]

See "Power Spectrum" and "Hubble Constant and 2018 Update" for more info about the formation of CMBR.

The observed fluctuation patterns are not the original ones generated in the inflationary era. Ordinary matter, dark matter, cosmic expansion, and gravity together have modified the appearance almost beyond recognition. It is from this jumbling mess that some of the cosmic parameters are extracted. In particular, the energy density in the inflation period is estimated to be about 10102 erg/cm3 from the measurement related to the left
Power Spectrum, Evolution of the "mountain" in Figure 05g. In order to prevent runaway gravitational fluctuation, it is believed that P(k) k for the mass density spectrum (Figure 05i). Subsequent interaction with the cold dark matter bends the curve as shown in Figure 05i. The large scale structures are in simpler form since there is no radiation to counteract the gravity. Although the CMBR spectrum also follows this scenario (Figure 05d, diagram a), its more complicated shape can be explained by further modifications (see "CMBR Power Spectrum").

Figure 05i Power Spectrum, Evolution [view large image]


A rough estimate of the thickness of the "Last Scattering Shell" (Figure 05h) : For ne ~ 103cm-3 (from Figure 01f), scatter = 6.65x10-25cm2; ~ 1021cm - about 10-2 times the observable cosmic size of 1023cm at recombination (see "History of the Universe").

In general relativity, distortions of the geometry (metric tensor) would induce quantum fluctuations similar to that in the scalar (inflaton) field in the form of gravitational wave. There are two components H generated in the early universe. It turns out that both of them obey the same equation for the k. The tensor power spectrum has the form : P(k) = (8/MP2)(H/2)2 implying low-energy inflation would produce negligible amounts of
Primordial Gravitational Wave gravitational waves. No primordial or any other forms of gravitational wave has been detected so far (up until 2014). However, indirect evidence has been observed in the B-mode polarization imprinted on the CMB (to be confirmed by further evaluations). As shown in Figure 05j, the B-mode polarization is subjected to contamination by many effects in the intervening space before its detection on Earth making its confirmation very difficult.

Figure 05j B-mode from Gravitational Wave