Home Page Overview Site Map Index Appendix Illustration About Contact Update FAQ

Quantum Field Theory

Quantum Vacuum (without Vacuum Catastrophe, 2019)

(Zero Point Energy, Quantum Fields and Vacuum Energy Density,
Hole Theory, Pair Creation and Annihilation)

Zero Point Energy

Virtual Particle In classical physics, empty space is called the vacuum. The classical vacuum is utterly featureless. However, in quantum theory, the vacuum is a much more complex entity. The uncertainty principle t E > allows virtual particles (each kind corresponding to a specific quantum field) continually materialize out of the vacuum for a short time and then vanish according to the uncertainty principle (Figure 05p).

Figure 05p Virtual Particle

Zero Point Energy Such movement means that there is a lowest energy level for the virtual particles. The lowest part of the quantum fields at vacuum state can be approximated by a harmonic oscillator at each spatial point as shown in Figure 05q. The lowest energy level has an energy E0 = /2 for n = 0 corresponding to no real particle according to "Quantum Field Theory" (QFT). Since there are an infinite number of harmonic oscillators per unit volume, the total zero-point energy density is, in fact, infinite. The process of renormalization is to move the zero point energy up to E0 so that En = n with n = 0, 1, 2, ... ; the infinity is thus removed. Such manipulation is justified by the fact that only the difference in energy is measurable. Now, the quantum vacuum is defined as no excitation of field quanta, i.e., no real particles are present. In other word, it is at a state of minimum (and zero) energy. The classical analogy would be a collection of motionless harmonic oscillators.

Figure 05q Zero Point Energy [view large image]

Quantum Fields and Vacuum Energy Density

Dark Energy Era The dominance of dark energy over matter occurred at about 7 billion years since the Big Bang according to some astronomical observations. It is found that only constant dark energy density or a very slowly varying one in standard cosmology can reproduce a rough match for this value of transitional time. All other forms proportional to 1/Rk (R is the scale factor) would fail the test (Figure 05u). The range of k that can produce a viable cross-over time is shown in the table below :

Figure 05u Dark Energy Era [view large image]

We are going to use the standard cosmological equation with the additional 1/Rk dependence on the cosmological "constant" term (time in unit of 1/H0), i.e.,

(dR/dt)2/R2 = m/R3 + /Rk, which can be recast to express the cosmic acceleration explicitly

(d2R/dt2) = R[- m/(2R3) + (1-k/2)/Rk] = 0 at cross-over time; then the scale factor

R = eq/(3-k), where q = ln(m) - ln[(2-k)], with m = 0.26, = 0.74; giving the red shift

z = (1-R)/R, while the cross-over time since Big Bang in Gyr (109 years)

T is computed by a Cosmic Calculator with the above parameters and 1/H0 = 13.7 Gyr (or H0 = 71.4 km/s-Mpc).

The role of dark energy in "Cyclic Universe" becomes the interacting agent between two oscillating 3-D branes. It also evolves along with each cycle (Figure 05v,a) moving from one false vacuum to another true vacuum, which is identified as the dark energy in that
Dark Energy in Cyclic Universe cycle. For example, in the current cycle where we happen to live in, the energy density of the false vacuum is about 10119 ergs/cm3. Such energy has been converted to various entities since then. The true vacuum has attained its current value of about 10-8 ergs/cm3 since the beginning of this cycle. Therefore, the calculated vacuum energy density of 10127 ergs/cm3 is not the dark energy, it is instead the energy released into this cycle of the universe (Figure 05v,b). This kind of consideration can be applied to

Figure 05v Dark Energy in Cyclic Universe [view large image]

other cosmological theory in general (such as the inflation theory) with the false vacuum energy density coming from some source.

It seems that the appearance of false vacuum was rather common in the early stage of the universe. For examples, the mechanism has been applied to the Higgs, axion, inflaton, and now a new kind of field in the cyclic universe. Nobody knows how to create a false vacuum, one suggestion by Alan Guth (the father of "Inflationary Universe") is to raise the temperature to about 1029 K, and then rapidly cooling it - similar to the condition in the inflation period posited in his theory.

A 2022 Novel Idea has resolved the discrepancy between calculated and observed Dark Energy.

Hole Theory

Negative Energy States Another kind of vacuum structure is prescribed by the Dirac theory of spin-1/2 particles in 1930. It admits the existence of both positive- and negative-energy particles: E = (m02c4 + p2c2)1/2. The concept of negative-energy entities is wholly alien to our knowledge of the universe. All things of physical significance are associated with varying amounts of positive energy. To get around the problem, Dirac proposed an energy spectrum containing all electrons in the universe (see Figure 06a). In addition to the normal positive-energy spectrum, it also contains the negative-energy variety, which spans the spectrum from -m0c2 down to negative infinity. All the negative-energy levels are filled, thus the positive-energy particle is inhibited from transition into these lower energy states. Thus, there is no observable effect in the real world. Only when there is enough energy available, e.g., E 2m0c2, a real particle and anti-particle pair with positive-energy can be created from this unseen sea of negative-energy particles. The particle is

Figure 06a Negative Energy [view large image]

the electron originally resided in the negative energy region, while the anti-particle (positron) can be interpreted as the hole in the vacated energy level acquiring a mass m0. The law of charge conservation demands that this anti-particle carries a positive charge.

The development of quantum field theory in the 1930's made it possible to treat the positron as a "real" particle rather than the absence of a particle, and makes the vacuum the state in which no real particles exist instead of an infinite sea of particles. It recaptures all the valid predictions of the Dirac sea, such as electron-positron annihilation.

Pair Creation and Annihilation

Reaction Ratio Closer examination of diagram (e), Figure 06a reveals that the intermediate product is a pair of quarks as shown in the insert within Figure 06b. The quark confinement process creates the observed hadrons in the final state. As the quarks are observed to be point-like (in deep inelastic scattering) and spin 1/2, the intermediate process e+e- q is very similar to the process e+e- +-, the only difference being that the charges on the quarks are only some fractions of that on the muons. This explains the constancy of the ratio R mentioned earlier and displayed in Figure 06b. As for the pronounced spikes

Figure 06b Reaction Ratio [view large image]

which punctuate the curve in Figure 06b. These shapes are formed at certain energies of the e+e- collision, when the q pair have just the correct mass to appear as a single-meson resonance. They are the SU(3) flavour symmetry mesons with mass ~ 1 Gev.
As the collision energies increase, new resonance spikes occur at 3.096 Gev and 3.687 Gev. It was discovered subsequently that they are the products of a new type of quark called "charm", which together with the "strange" quark form the second generation of quark. With this discovery the number of mesons is expanded into the 16-plet of spin-0 mesons generated by SU(4) flavour symmetry. Similarly, the spikes at 10 Gev and 10.40 Gev in Figure 06b lead to the discovery of the bottom quark for the third generation. The SU(4) flavour symmetry has to be enlarged to SU(5) so that the basic multiplet of spin-0 mesons is now expanded to a 25-plet. It is further realized that
Meson Spectrum the c mesons form a spectrum from the different values for the spin and the orbital angular momentum of the constituent quarks as shown in Figure 06c. In the same notation for the atomic spectra, S, P and D in the diagram refer respectively to orbital angular momentum 0, , and 2. The resemblance to the atomic spectrum is understandable because of asymptotic freedom as the c and bound themselves together loosely. The force between the quarks can be formulated as a potential acting in the vicinity of a colour charge. Thus instead of the Coulomb potential in the case of the atom, the quarks interact via the potential:

Figure 06c [view large image] Meson Spectrum

V = - 4s / (3r) + ar ,

with which the Schrodinger equation in non-relativistic quantum mechanics yields a most satisfactory match to the observed meson mass level (see Figure 06c). This formula combines a Coulomb potential at short ranges with an attractive potential rising linearly at longer distance, giving rise to the ever-increasing forces of quark confinement. Thus, the masses of the c mesons provide direct support for the QCD picture of inter-quark forces containing both asymptotic freedom at short ranges and confining forces at longer distance. As the beam energy is increased, the quark and antiquark are produced with very large momenta, moving in opposite directions known as
Jets two-jet event. The fragmentation into hadrons then takes place, preferentially along the direction of the motion the quark and antiquark, resulting in jets of hadrons which become more and more collimated as energy is increased (see left diagram of Figure 06d). The measurement of the angular distribution of jet axes confirms that the spin of quarks is indeed 1/2. At even higher energy the quark or antiquark radiating a gluon, which forms a separate jet of its own.

Figure 06d Two- and Three-Jet Event [view large image]

This three-jet event is shown in the right diagram of Fgiure 06d.

The pair creation mentioned above requires the presence of an atomic nucleus to maintain conservation of momentum and to provide the second photon to complete the process, which is second order (meaning proportional to =e2/c and related to the # of interaction points) with cross section (~ probability) about 1 barn (~ 10-24 cm2). For pair creation truly plucks out from vacuum, the process is fourth order
Schwinger Limit with a much smaller cross section ~ 10-7 b as shown in Figure 06e, in which, diagram (a) shows the photon-photon scattering when E < 2mc2. The process that produces the pair out of the vacuum requires very high photon intensity (such as very powerful laser not yet invented) to compensate for the much lower cross section. The diagram on the right shows the various laser facilities over the years. It predicts the laser capability could reach such requirement (the "Schwinger limit") by 2030.

Figure 06e Schwinger Limit [view large image]

See "What's inside nothing? This laser will rip it up to find out", New Scientist, January 26-February 1, 2019 for the world's most intense laser at ELI (Extreme Light Infra-structure) in Romania, 2019.

The next topic is about the Higgs field, which prescribes yet another kind of structure in the quantum vacuum.

Go to Next Section
 or to Top of Page to Select
 or to Main Menu